Recent orders
the character, Othello.
Othello.
Othello is the title of the character and play that we all studied earlier this semester. However, it is Othello the character that I intend to discuss. Othello is the husband to the beautiful and innocent Desdemona, whom he murders because the villainous and honest Iago has misled him. A Moorish general in Venice, a society plagued with racism and where adultery is neither condemned nor approved of, Othello is in the midst of a society that will hinder and not support his progress.
The central theme of the drama is the alteration of a noble lover to a raving killer, under the influence of the deliberate connivance of his aide, Iago, who convinces him that his wife is having a love affair with another officer named Cassio.
Unable to trust the falsely corrupted Desdemona – he lacks the essential element of love and it is this absence of trust that causes Othello to disintegrate morally. This destructiveness extends to his own suicide, when his error of judging Desdemona to be an adulteress fails him. Our closely woven relationship with this traumatised and gullible Othello causes us to suffer with him, as he experiences emotional agonies, such as the destruction of his once reputable nobility, character and marriage to the young Desdemona.
Through Act II, Scene I, Othello presents himself to us as a grandly positive and content character,
“It gives me wonder great as my content
To see you here before me. O my soul’s joy!”
(Act II, Scene II).
At this stage in the play Othello has also assembled his character to impose on us an impression, that he is a noble and prominent figure in the Venetian establishment, and respected military man and a loving husband. He carries himself with an impressive dignity while frankly delighting in his young wife’s unconditional love, which he values above the “seas worth”, (Act II, Scene I). When the couple defend their marriage against the prejudiced Brabantio, father to Desdemona, who associates Othello with witchcraft, (because Othello is black), in Act I, Scene III, it becomes evident that the couple share an unconditional love for one another.
However, in the second half of the play Othello abandons this perfect love, for a blind and unfounded jealousy too strong to act in a just manner. He loses all faith not only in Desdemona, but especially himself,
“That’s he that was Othello; Here I am.”
(Act V, Scene II).
Othello says this subsequently, as a result of materialising his now hopeless spirit – it was led to this through the work of a conniving Iago. When he rejects her love and trust in Act V, Scene II, when about to kill her, he allows an incurable self-centeredness to overtake his misled mind.
After collapsing in Act IV, Scene I, Othello can only babble as he falls to the feet of Iago in a trance. This event illustrates and enhances the sad fact that Othello has fallen to the intentions of Iago. Othello recovers his wits, but from this occurrence he has only one goal – to kill Desdemona and her alleged lover, Cassio. With this intent it becomes painfully obvious that Othello now possesses the resentful will held by Iago, who despises Othello, and associates him initially to bestial sex acts, shadowed by a vile racism. “I hate the Moor”, is plain and to the point, and “an old black ram Is tupping your white ewe”, (Act I, Scenes I-II), creates a feeling of disgust.
Nonetheless, as the play procedes, Othello even comes to resemble the villain in his speech, using staccato or broken repetitions and he also makes an unhealthy habit of using violent, sexual and animal imagery,
“I’ll chop her into messes,” and;
“I will be found most cunning in my patience”
(Act IV, Scene I), are appropriate examples.
In Act IV, Scene II Othello indulges in a great exaggeration of his jealousy when he believes Desdemona to be a prostitute, and Emila, the wife of Iago t be her pimp,
“She says enough; yet she’s a simple bawd
That cannot say as much. This is a subtle whore,
A closet lock and key of villainous secrets,
And yet she’ll kneel and pray; I have seen her do’t.”
(Act IV, Scene II).
In the end though, Othello still manages to contemplate his love for his wife when he sees her asleep. Sadly as a demonstration of his foully motivated ambition he kills her with a coolness which is frightening. His reaction to the discovery of her true innocence is, however, in stark contrast. He recognises that he is no longer noble, for he calls himself: “He that was Othello”, in Act V, Scene II. Othello also equates himself to the heathens he used to slaughter and kill himself.
Iago can effect this extraordinary response only because Othello is lacking in trust. This lack is implicit in the Moor’s situation from the start, for he cannot partake of the social cohesion that encourages and reinforces trust between humans. The fact that he is in effect an alien in Venice – he is black, a mercenary soldier in a very biased society. I feel it is this insecurity that forbids the entrance of trust into Othello’s environment.
Importantly, Othello, once distracted, is not capable of appreciating Desdemona; he knows enough of Venice to see its prejudice, but he does not recognise her amazing courage in opposing it. Like Macbeth, Othello has succeeded as a soldier, and is accordingly left with a dignity and pride but misunderstands the world outside the military one.
With his suicide Othello acknowledges his fault, but his final recognition of Desdemona’s goodness offers us some kind of consoling sense that is dying he retrieves some of his once dominant nobility.
Othello has returned to sanity too late, but at least that provides us with some reconciliation. Finally, Othello’s fate shows us that a noble person may fall to the depths of savagery, but a small dose of humanity may still remain. This commentary of Othello the character is brief, but I hope it has made you appreciate and discover some aspects of the multi-dimensional character of Othello.
AE4 Source evaluation template
AE4 Source evaluation template
Instructions
1. Click the link to download the AE4 source evaluation template.
2. Upload the document to the OneDrive folder you have shared with your teacher.
3. Rename the file: name.studentnumber.source_evaluation e.g. jimmy.wong.3143223.source_evaluation
4. Complete the first source evaluation for your extended essay by week 3.
5. Complete the second source evaluation for your group presentation by week 6.
6. Make notes next to each of the CRAP criteria headings in the table. Use the questions to help you.
7. Write your evaluative summary paragraph at the end of your notes in the space provided. You should write 180-200 words.
8. Save and upload to Canvas by the due date.
9.Share a copy of your source text with your teacher, by uploading a copy of the text to the shared OneDrive folder. Name your source text file with your name and student number in the file name, e.g. Jimmy.Wong.3143233.source_text.docx
Source evaluation: Extended essay (Week 3)
Topic /question Assess the importance of GDP in measuring a selected country’s economic wellbeing
Reference details
(author, date, title etc.) Trewin, D. (2001). Measuring wellbeing. Australian Bureau of Statistics.
Type of source journal article news article
report other ___________________________
C.R.A.P. criteria Your response (in note form)
Currency
Why the date of publication of the source is appropriate. 2001. While the article is almost two decades old, it still retains relevance as it discusses the issue of determining the wellbeing gof Australia.
Relevance
How this source is relevant to your assessment task. Looks at the measures of wellbeing relevant to Australia
Attempts to introduce measures outside of financial and economic status
Defines GDP and its application in Australia
Compares wellbeing of the country with New Zealand in terms of GDP
Looks at a suite of indicators and other subject measures of wellbeing
Authority
What expertise the author has or uses. Article approved by the Australian Bureau of Statistics.
Chair, Advisory Board of Australia’s National Development Index
Purpose
Why the text was written, and who it was written for. Written for the scholarly community as a contribution to literature
Summary of why this source is suitable for your extended essay/presentation:
This article discusses approaches to measuring progress and wellbeing. It also looks at he modalities foe developing measures of wellbeing and focuses its case on Australia. It compares the use of GDP in Australia with the Australian National Development Index. For comparative purposes it briefly looks at how New Zealand measures progress and provides recommendations for the future. This source is important because it focuses on Australia’s perspective of the GDP against other measures.
Source evaluation: Group presentation (Week 6)
Topic /question Assess the importance of GDP in measuring a selected country’s economic wellbeing
Reference details
(author, date, title etc.) Kenny, D. C., Costanza, R., Dowsley, T., Jackson, N., Josol, J., Kubiszewski, I., … & Thompson, J. (2019). Australia’s genuine progress indicator revisited (1962–2013). Ecological Economics, 158, 1-10.
Type of source journal article news article
report other ___________________________
C.R.A.P. criteria Your response (in note form)
Currency
Why the date of publication of the source is appropriate. 2019- Up to date and relevant
Relevance
How this source is relevant to your assessment task. This article not only discusses the importance of GDP as an indicator of progress and wellbeing in Australia but also looks at alternatives including the inclusion of ecological factors and other relevant concepts.
Authority
What expertise the author has or uses. Published under Australian National University
Endorsed by the journal of Ecological Economics
Purpose
Why the text was written, and who it was written for. Written for the Australian scholarly audience
Summary of why this source is suitable for your extended essay/presentation:
The authors look at how Australia has continued to measure progress and wellbeing from the mid-20th century up to 2013. It then proceeds to attempt to provide a genuine progress indicator by combining other measures to supplement the use of GDP. It mentions the long term use of Measures of Australia’s Progress (MAP) in Australia including a collection of alternative indicators. It then discusses the GDP and its pros and cons in measuring public welfare.
AE4 Research tracker
AE4 Research tracker
Student details
Name:
Student ID:
Contents:
Key topic wordsExampleExtended essay sourcesGroup presentation sourcesKey topic words
Extended essay:
GDP, Australia, welfare, economic wellbeing, indicators,
Group presentation:
Essay sources
Essay question:
Assess the importance of GDP in measuring a selected country’s economic wellbeing
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Joseph E. Stiglitz. (2020,August 1). GDP Is the Wrong Tool for Measuring What Matters. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gdp-is-the-wrong-tool-for-measuring-what-matters/ Online publication/news article 20.08.2021
Comments
Summary:
Useful information on the use of GDP as a measure of public welfare and goes ahead to dissect the reasons why its use should be stopped or improved to include other indicators beyond market activities.
Measures of economic wellbeing
Useful information on strategies:
Defining GDP
Understanding it is used as a measure of economic and societal welfare all over the world
Use of GDP
Why it should be improved or supplemented to ensure that total welfare of a society is well captured
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Aitken, A. (2019). Measuring welfare beyond GDP. National Institute economic review, 249, R3-R16. https://doi.org/10.1177/002795011924900110Journal Article 20.08.2021
Comments
Summary:
A useful review of GDP as a measure of economic welfare, asserting how it is misused in that regard (R11)
It sheds light on the proper use of GDP (R4-R7)
Presents reasons why it should not be used without the inclusion of other critical indicators that reflect overall progress of a society (R4-R9)
Useful information:
Rich and informative explanations on the GDP as a measure of economic health
Relevant and up to date content
Provides a starting point to answer the question on GDP as an economic health measure
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Kenny, D. C., Costanza, R., Dowsley, T., Jackson, N., Josol, J., Kubiszewski, I., … & Thompson, J. (2019). Australia’s genuine progress indicator revisited (1962–2013). Ecological Economics, 158, 1-10 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2018.11.025 Journal Article 20.08.2021
Comments
Evaluation:
This article not only discusses the importance of GDP as an indicator of progress and wellbeing in Australia but also looks at alternatives including the inclusion of ecological factors and other relevant concepts.
Summary:
Looks at how Australia has continued to measure progress and wellbeing from the mid-20th century up to 2013 (p2-p4)
Provides a genuine progress indicator by combining other measures to supplement the use of GDP (p3-p4)
Mentions the long term use of Measures of Australia’s Progress (MAP) in Australia including a collection of alternative indicators (p4-p7)
Discusses the GDP and its pros and cons in measuring public welfare (p4-p6)
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Trewin, D. (2001). Measuring wellbeing. Australian Bureau of Statistics. https://www.governanceinstitute.edu.au/magma/media/upload/ckeditor/files/Well-being%20presentation.pdfJournal 20.08.2021
Comments
Evaluation:
The article looks at the measures of wellbeing relevant to Australia and attempts to introduce measures outside of financial and economic status. Defines GDP and its application in Australia and compares wellbeing of the country with New Zealand in terms of GDP, and finally looks at a suite of indicators and other subject measures of wellbeing.
Summary:
Discusses approaches to measuring progress and wellbeing including types of indicators (P9)
Looks at the modalities foe developing measures of wellbeing and focuses its case on Australia (p8)
Specifically looks at the measures of Australia’s progress (p10)
Compares the use of GDP in Australia with the Australian National Development Index (p13)
For comparative purposes it briefly looks at how New Zealand measures progress and provides recommendations for the future (p26)
Important because it focuses on Australia’s perspective of the GDP against other measures (p15-p20)
Group presentation sources
Presentation topic:
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Comments
Summary:
Evaluation:
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Comments
Summary:
Evaluation:
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Comments
Summary:
Evaluation:
Full APA reference Source type Date accessed
Comments
Summary:
Evaluation:
